Trauma-Informed CBT vs Trauma-Focused CBT: What's the Difference?
If you've been looking for therapy, you may have come across both trauma-informed CBT and trauma-focused CBT.
But what is the difference between trauma-informed CBT vs trauma-focused CBT?
The names sound very similar.
But they don't necessarily mean the same thing.
And importantly, one isn't better than the other.
They are different approaches designed for different difficulties, presentations and goals.
Trauma-Focused CBT: When the Trauma Itself Is the Focus
Trauma-focused CBT is specifically designed to help people who are experiencing difficulties related directly to a traumatic event or events.
This might include symptoms such as:
Flashbacks or intrusive memories
Nightmares
Avoidance of reminders of what happened
Feeling constantly on edge or unsafe
Strong feelings of guilt, shame or fear related to the trauma
Difficulties associated with PTSD
In trauma-focused therapy, we work more directly with the traumatic experience and the way it continues to affect you now.
The goal isn't simply to understand that something difficult happened.
It's to help your brain process what happened so that the memories, meanings and reminders of the trauma no longer have the same hold over your life.
Trauma-Informed CBT: Understanding the Context Behind the Pattern
Trauma-informed CBT is different.
It doesn't necessarily mean that the trauma itself is the focus of treatment.
Instead, it means recognising that difficult experiences may have shaped the way you see
yourself, other people and the world around you.
For example, someone might come to therapy struggling with:
People-pleasing
Perfectionism
Chronic self-criticism
Difficulty trusting others
Feeling responsible for other people's emotions
Anxiety
Difficulty setting boundaries
Their therapy might explore how earlier experiences contributed to these patterns.
But that doesn't necessarily mean the goal is to process a specific traumatic memory.
The goal may instead be to understand:
"How did this pattern develop?"
"What was it trying to protect me from?"
"Is it still helping me now?"
And:
"What would I like to do differently?"
Trauma-Informed Therapy Isn't "Less Than"
I recently came across the idea that:
"Trauma-informed therapy isn't enough to treat trauma."
And there is an important distinction here.
If the goal of therapy is to directly treat PTSD or process the impact of traumatic memories, then a trauma-focused approach may be needed.
But that doesn't mean trauma-informed CBT is an inferior or watered-down version of trauma therapy.
It simply isn't trying to do exactly the same thing.
Think of It Like an Injury 🩹
Imagine you've been injured.
Sometimes treatment needs to focus directly on the injury itself.
The wound may need attention in order to heal.
This is a little like trauma-focused therapy.
When someone is experiencing difficulties such as PTSD, intrusive memories, flashbacks or significant distress connected to a traumatic experience, therapy may need to work directly with the trauma and its ongoing impact.
But injuries can also affect the way we move long after the original injury.
We might compensate.
Avoid certain movements.
Or develop new ways of protecting ourselves.
Even when those adaptations initially helped, they can sometimes begin causing difficulties of their own.
This is where a trauma-informed approach can be helpful.
It helps us understand how difficult experiences may have shaped the way you think, feel, behave and protect yourself today.
Perhaps you learnt to avoid conflict.
Perhaps you became hyperaware of other people's moods.
Perhaps you learnt that being perfect felt safer.
Perhaps putting everyone else's needs first helped you maintain important relationships.
These patterns didn't appear randomly.
They may have developed as adaptations.
Trauma-focused CBT might focus directly on the injury itself.
Trauma-informed CBT might help us understand how you've adapted around it.
Neither is "more" than the other.
They simply have a different focus.
(If you'd like to learn more about what trauma-informed CBT therapy can actually look like, you can read more about my approach here.)
Sometimes the Approach Changes
Therapy also isn't always as simple as choosing one approach and staying there forever.
What we focus on depends on your individual difficulties and what you want to achieve.
For some people, trauma-focused work may be the most appropriate starting point.
For others, the main difficulty may not be a traumatic memory itself, but the patterns and beliefs that developed over time.
And sometimes, different approaches may be appropriate at different points in therapy.
This is why I don't believe therapy should be about fitting someone neatly into a particular
box.
The most important question is:
What is happening for you now - and what do you need help with?
The Goal Is the Right Approach for You
I offer both trauma-informed CBT and trauma-focused CBT because different people need different things.
You don't need to arrive knowing which approach is right for you.
That's something we can explore together.
The aim isn't to decide which type of therapy is "better".
It's to understand what you are struggling with, what may be contributing to those difficulties and what kind of support is most likely to help.
Because good therapy isn't about applying the same approach to everyone.
It's about understanding the person sitting in front of you.
And deciding, together, where the work needs to begin.
Taking the First Step
If you're unsure whether trauma-informed CBT, trauma-focused CBT or another approach might be right for you, you don't need to figure that out alone.
I offer a free 15-minute consultation where we can talk about what you're experiencing, what you're hoping to get from therapy and whether working together feels like the right fit.
Instagram - @cbtwithjo
Website - www.cbtwithjo.co.uk
Email - jo@cbtwithjo.co.uk
Comments